Thursday, September 21, 2006
Warning: Educational Content
I was going to write an email about a typical day in my life, but I
got a little sidetracked and instead wrote a little case study about
my previous email. I will get to a fun and substantial update in due
time, but frankly I'm exhausted at this point and will leave you with
the following long and self-indulgent email. This may be tedious for
some so don't feel compelled to read it...
ABA for Beginners
Some background:
Most of you know that last school year I worked through the special ed
department of an elementary school in an upper-class city in Southern
California. My exploits there are well-documented and fodder for all
kinds of hilarious anecdotes, many of which have been related in
previous communiques. That gig led me to my present employment:
Behavior Technician for a non-profit corporation called SEEK
Education, which stands for...um, I forget, but one of the E's is
"Education," which makes our acronym amusingly redundant for those of
us easily entertained. Our clients are generally comprised of children
with autism.
My particular discipline is called "Applied Behavior Analysis," more
crudely referred to as "Behavior Modification." Sounds like
brain-washing, and that is exactly what it is, because one of the
first rules of ABA is that humans have no free will but simply respond
to external stimuli. My work is based on the research pioneered by
Pavlov (what is his first name?) and B.F. Skinner, a psychologist
whose name you might recognize because he shares the same last name as
the principal on "The Simpsons." Given B.F. Skinner's influence on
classroom management and education, no doubt the creators of our
favorite nuclear family were making a joke that only about nine people
get.
How does ABA work? if you weren't wondering this, then
congratulations, I'll send you a cookie in the mail because either a)
you knew how it works or b) you didn't care. Either way, I'm sleeping
well tonight. Anyway, Skinner and his cronies asserted that there are
only 4 functions of human behavior, and anything a person does can be
shown to fulfill one or more of these purposes. They are: 1. Attention
2. Access to Tangibles 3. Sensory Stimulation 4. Escape/Avoidance. A
quick example, I am writing this account for the Attention it gives
me. In fact, most of my behavior falls under the Attention category.
A lot of what I do deals with modifying behavior excesses. Spitting,
hitting, yelling, screaming, running away, throwing tantrums, biting,
public masturbation, lying on the floor--these are a few examples of
what are traditionally considered behavior excesses (these are not the
things I do, they are what the kids do...but you got that, right?).
The definition of a behavior excess has 3 criteria: 1. It must be
measurable. 2. It must be specific. 3. It interferes with learning or
some other task. I often must discover the cause of the behavior
excess, and do this through the ABC process:
Antecedent (what happened before the excess occurred and the
circumstances in which it happened), Behavior, Consequence.
If I may reference myself, I will give a case demonstration using my
previous email (and we all know that I may reference myself, since I
am my favorite subject). If you recall, a young boy would not heed his
mother to simply go up the stairs. In ABC format, this is what that
situation looks like (scroll down so you can see it as a whole:
A B
C
Date: 9/18/06 Child giggled 4 times Mom continued to
When: 8:30 pm walked away from verbally
instruct child
With who: Mom, Mom towards "down" to go to the "up"
random strangers escalator. Child stayed escalator.
Task: Walk up stairs near "down" escalator
Setting Events: for 45 seconds.
After shopping, at base
of elevator/stairs
in downtown shopping
area. Mom gave
instruction to Son
to "Go up stairs."
This tells me that the child was behaving in such a way as to draw the
Attention of his mother. It doesn't matter that she was frustrated and
scolding him, he just wanted her attention and he was getting it and
enjoying the heck out of it. It is my professional opinion that his
behavior had a secondary function: Avoidance (of the task). Why I put
them in this heirarchy is a matter of conjecture based on a single
incident, but as my analysis will illustrate, if mom wasn't there, the
kid wouldn't be behaving as he was.
Key Term: Reinforcement. This is any stimulus that increases a
behavior by corresponding to one or more of the four functions of
behavior. In this scenario, mom's vocalizations and eye contact were
reinforcing the behavior excess because the child's behavior
increased/continued.
Mom had some choices:
1. She could have ignored her child and continued up the stairs. The
child would be derived of her attention and would have followed her
right up. Some people would say that it would be irresponsible to
"leave your child", but seriously, that kid would have bolted up the
stairs or taken the escalator within seconds if she had pretended that
he wasn't there. Additionally, he would have realized that the
consequences for his behavior would be more unpleasant than if he
modified his behavior to go up the stairs (i.e. left alone in downtown
LA).
2. Mom could have physically prompted the child after the first
defiance. This would have required her to walk over the the child and
simply bring him up. Keeping in mind that the primary function of his
behavior was Attention, she would have had to ignore him while doing
this as well. She would go get him without speaking to him after the
second instruction and not talk to him until he complied with her. But
this option runs the risk of "reinforcing" the behavior, especially if
he decides he can out-maneuver mom. If that happens, the primary
function of his behavior shifts to "Escape/Avoidance." This option is
also not desirable because the child lacks sufficient motivation to
follow mom's instructions, unless she makes the experience
sufficiently unpleasant so that he will comply next time--this would
be called "negative reinforcement" (removing an unpleasant stimulus,
in this case being dragged around, to increase a behavior), but we are
getting ahead of ourselves.
3. She could have offered some reward for her son for doing what she
asked. "I'll give you some candy when you get to the top." But the
main flaw here is that she would have already had to possess the
candy. She could have promised him candy or a preferred activity when
they got home, but that prospect would be somewhat abstract for the
child because it represents some time in the future that is not
temporally related to his behavior.
So when I came on the scene, I gave the child a small amount of
attention by offering to race up the stairs. Implicit in this offer
was the promise of more attention when the race was
completed--reinforcing the behavior of going up the stairs. The ABC
looks like this:
A: B:
C:
Date: 9/18/06 The child ran up The child was at the
When: 8:31 pm the stairs. top of
the stairs and
With who: BB
given verbal feedback.
Task: going up the stairs
Setting Events: BB
said "Hey man, wanna
race?" to the child, the
child said yes. BB said
"Ready, set, go."
This format works best with young children and children with
developmental disorders. I would love to hang out with George W. Bush
with my little ABC charts, I'm sure he'd be putty (puddy?) in my
hands.
Behind behavioral pyschology is the assumption that, given the proper
motivation, humans will behave in ways that they do not normally
behave. This explains how ordinary people do extraordinary things, or
why someone may act incongruently with their moral convictions or
previous patterns of behavior.
This works with any person in any situation, and it works for other
animals as well. It's a fun lens with which to view the world, and it
begs many philisophical questions regarding "the meaning of life"
one's "purpose." Some of us don't believe in such things to begin
with, so finding out that everything I do can be boiled down to four
basic functions is no big shock.
But Ben, you say, what about learning for learning's sake? What do you
say to such an abstraction?
Well kids, learning for learning's sake serves many functions. For
example, let's say you want to learn about some obscure architectural
technique and you think you are doing it because of natural
curiousity. Nope. Natural curiousity doesn't exist. Most likely you
are learning about that subject in great detail so you can work it
into a conversation (Attention). Or maybe you just like looking at
buildings (Sensory). Or maybe, through working it into conversation
with a boss, you impress your boss, and you get a raise and can now
afford to buy more things (Access to Tangibles). Or you donate that
raise to charity, say Save the Rainforests (Avoidance...of unpleasant
environmental consequences of deforestation that threaten your health
or the economy and we're back to Access to Tangibles) or an
Anti-Abortion group (Avoidance of the supposed destructive
consequences of abortion on society, rediculous as those claims are).
With these emails I receive the reinforcement that I seek when my
friends write back to tell me how much my communique's suck. If I sent
out ten emails over a period of time and never heard from anyone, you
would witness something called "extinction." This is when a behavior
goes away because it is no longer functional. The trick is to withold
the reinforcement. At first, you will see the behavior increase out of
desparation and you would be tempted to reinforce it because that
would temporarily make the behavior go away. However, if you can hold
out through that increase in behavior, it will just one day stop.
Allow me to indulge one more example. Here is the scenario:
A particular child enjoys playing outside with his "water table."
Whenever his parents made him go inside, he would throw a big fit with
crying and other tantrum behaviors. My colleagues and I developed a
plan to give the child a verbal warning when he had 2 minutes left to
be outside, then 1 minute left, then a countdown from 10. We
instructed mom and dad to ignore the tantrums, which we suspected were
being reinforced by coddling or additional outside time. The first
time we implemented this, there was the expected tantrum. The second
time, same deal. The third time, however, the child severely decreased
his tantrum to a mere whine. The fourth time the child did not protest
at all. Now we are at the point where he voluntarily goes inside. We
looked like certified geniuses, and all we had to do was to convince
mom and dad to act counter-intuitively a few times and presto! No more
tears :)
got a little sidetracked and instead wrote a little case study about
my previous email. I will get to a fun and substantial update in due
time, but frankly I'm exhausted at this point and will leave you with
the following long and self-indulgent email. This may be tedious for
some so don't feel compelled to read it...
ABA for Beginners
Some background:
Most of you know that last school year I worked through the special ed
department of an elementary school in an upper-class city in Southern
California. My exploits there are well-documented and fodder for all
kinds of hilarious anecdotes, many of which have been related in
previous communiques. That gig led me to my present employment:
Behavior Technician for a non-profit corporation called SEEK
Education, which stands for...um, I forget, but one of the E's is
"Education," which makes our acronym amusingly redundant for those of
us easily entertained. Our clients are generally comprised of children
with autism.
My particular discipline is called "Applied Behavior Analysis," more
crudely referred to as "Behavior Modification." Sounds like
brain-washing, and that is exactly what it is, because one of the
first rules of ABA is that humans have no free will but simply respond
to external stimuli. My work is based on the research pioneered by
Pavlov (what is his first name?) and B.F. Skinner, a psychologist
whose name you might recognize because he shares the same last name as
the principal on "The Simpsons." Given B.F. Skinner's influence on
classroom management and education, no doubt the creators of our
favorite nuclear family were making a joke that only about nine people
get.
How does ABA work? if you weren't wondering this, then
congratulations, I'll send you a cookie in the mail because either a)
you knew how it works or b) you didn't care. Either way, I'm sleeping
well tonight. Anyway, Skinner and his cronies asserted that there are
only 4 functions of human behavior, and anything a person does can be
shown to fulfill one or more of these purposes. They are: 1. Attention
2. Access to Tangibles 3. Sensory Stimulation 4. Escape/Avoidance. A
quick example, I am writing this account for the Attention it gives
me. In fact, most of my behavior falls under the Attention category.
A lot of what I do deals with modifying behavior excesses. Spitting,
hitting, yelling, screaming, running away, throwing tantrums, biting,
public masturbation, lying on the floor--these are a few examples of
what are traditionally considered behavior excesses (these are not the
things I do, they are what the kids do...but you got that, right?).
The definition of a behavior excess has 3 criteria: 1. It must be
measurable. 2. It must be specific. 3. It interferes with learning or
some other task. I often must discover the cause of the behavior
excess, and do this through the ABC process:
Antecedent (what happened before the excess occurred and the
circumstances in which it happened), Behavior, Consequence.
If I may reference myself, I will give a case demonstration using my
previous email (and we all know that I may reference myself, since I
am my favorite subject). If you recall, a young boy would not heed his
mother to simply go up the stairs. In ABC format, this is what that
situation looks like (scroll down so you can see it as a whole:
A B
C
Date: 9/18/06 Child giggled 4 times Mom continued to
When: 8:30 pm walked away from verbally
instruct child
With who: Mom, Mom towards "down" to go to the "up"
random strangers escalator. Child stayed escalator.
Task: Walk up stairs near "down" escalator
Setting Events: for 45 seconds.
After shopping, at base
of elevator/stairs
in downtown shopping
area. Mom gave
instruction to Son
to "Go up stairs."
This tells me that the child was behaving in such a way as to draw the
Attention of his mother. It doesn't matter that she was frustrated and
scolding him, he just wanted her attention and he was getting it and
enjoying the heck out of it. It is my professional opinion that his
behavior had a secondary function: Avoidance (of the task). Why I put
them in this heirarchy is a matter of conjecture based on a single
incident, but as my analysis will illustrate, if mom wasn't there, the
kid wouldn't be behaving as he was.
Key Term: Reinforcement. This is any stimulus that increases a
behavior by corresponding to one or more of the four functions of
behavior. In this scenario, mom's vocalizations and eye contact were
reinforcing the behavior excess because the child's behavior
increased/continued.
Mom had some choices:
1. She could have ignored her child and continued up the stairs. The
child would be derived of her attention and would have followed her
right up. Some people would say that it would be irresponsible to
"leave your child", but seriously, that kid would have bolted up the
stairs or taken the escalator within seconds if she had pretended that
he wasn't there. Additionally, he would have realized that the
consequences for his behavior would be more unpleasant than if he
modified his behavior to go up the stairs (i.e. left alone in downtown
LA).
2. Mom could have physically prompted the child after the first
defiance. This would have required her to walk over the the child and
simply bring him up. Keeping in mind that the primary function of his
behavior was Attention, she would have had to ignore him while doing
this as well. She would go get him without speaking to him after the
second instruction and not talk to him until he complied with her. But
this option runs the risk of "reinforcing" the behavior, especially if
he decides he can out-maneuver mom. If that happens, the primary
function of his behavior shifts to "Escape/Avoidance." This option is
also not desirable because the child lacks sufficient motivation to
follow mom's instructions, unless she makes the experience
sufficiently unpleasant so that he will comply next time--this would
be called "negative reinforcement" (removing an unpleasant stimulus,
in this case being dragged around, to increase a behavior), but we are
getting ahead of ourselves.
3. She could have offered some reward for her son for doing what she
asked. "I'll give you some candy when you get to the top." But the
main flaw here is that she would have already had to possess the
candy. She could have promised him candy or a preferred activity when
they got home, but that prospect would be somewhat abstract for the
child because it represents some time in the future that is not
temporally related to his behavior.
So when I came on the scene, I gave the child a small amount of
attention by offering to race up the stairs. Implicit in this offer
was the promise of more attention when the race was
completed--reinforcing the behavior of going up the stairs. The ABC
looks like this:
A: B:
C:
Date: 9/18/06 The child ran up The child was at the
When: 8:31 pm the stairs. top of
the stairs and
With who: BB
given verbal feedback.
Task: going up the stairs
Setting Events: BB
said "Hey man, wanna
race?" to the child, the
child said yes. BB said
"Ready, set, go."
This format works best with young children and children with
developmental disorders. I would love to hang out with George W. Bush
with my little ABC charts, I'm sure he'd be putty (puddy?) in my
hands.
Behind behavioral pyschology is the assumption that, given the proper
motivation, humans will behave in ways that they do not normally
behave. This explains how ordinary people do extraordinary things, or
why someone may act incongruently with their moral convictions or
previous patterns of behavior.
This works with any person in any situation, and it works for other
animals as well. It's a fun lens with which to view the world, and it
begs many philisophical questions regarding "the meaning of life"
one's "purpose." Some of us don't believe in such things to begin
with, so finding out that everything I do can be boiled down to four
basic functions is no big shock.
But Ben, you say, what about learning for learning's sake? What do you
say to such an abstraction?
Well kids, learning for learning's sake serves many functions. For
example, let's say you want to learn about some obscure architectural
technique and you think you are doing it because of natural
curiousity. Nope. Natural curiousity doesn't exist. Most likely you
are learning about that subject in great detail so you can work it
into a conversation (Attention). Or maybe you just like looking at
buildings (Sensory). Or maybe, through working it into conversation
with a boss, you impress your boss, and you get a raise and can now
afford to buy more things (Access to Tangibles). Or you donate that
raise to charity, say Save the Rainforests (Avoidance...of unpleasant
environmental consequences of deforestation that threaten your health
or the economy and we're back to Access to Tangibles) or an
Anti-Abortion group (Avoidance of the supposed destructive
consequences of abortion on society, rediculous as those claims are).
With these emails I receive the reinforcement that I seek when my
friends write back to tell me how much my communique's suck. If I sent
out ten emails over a period of time and never heard from anyone, you
would witness something called "extinction." This is when a behavior
goes away because it is no longer functional. The trick is to withold
the reinforcement. At first, you will see the behavior increase out of
desparation and you would be tempted to reinforce it because that
would temporarily make the behavior go away. However, if you can hold
out through that increase in behavior, it will just one day stop.
Allow me to indulge one more example. Here is the scenario:
A particular child enjoys playing outside with his "water table."
Whenever his parents made him go inside, he would throw a big fit with
crying and other tantrum behaviors. My colleagues and I developed a
plan to give the child a verbal warning when he had 2 minutes left to
be outside, then 1 minute left, then a countdown from 10. We
instructed mom and dad to ignore the tantrums, which we suspected were
being reinforced by coddling or additional outside time. The first
time we implemented this, there was the expected tantrum. The second
time, same deal. The third time, however, the child severely decreased
his tantrum to a mere whine. The fourth time the child did not protest
at all. Now we are at the point where he voluntarily goes inside. We
looked like certified geniuses, and all we had to do was to convince
mom and dad to act counter-intuitively a few times and presto! No more
tears :)