Sunday, January 07, 2007

 

The Advantage of Living Alone and the Trouble with Humanism

The Advantage of Living Alone and the Trouble with Humanism


In the last thirty-six hour period, I read George Orwell's 1984. I know it's trite to sing praises of well-established literature, but it really can't be helped. I can avoid hyperbole when I say that it is a novel that sheds light on a great many contemporary political shennanigans. It did force me to realize, however, that we have a rather soft totalitarian state when compared with some of the more notorious of the bunch, but it should be pointed out that this does not render the state docile.

The great flaw in humanism is its reliance on the good will and intelligence of others. I recently was entangled in a situation where my acts of good will were abused deliberately. The perpetrator keenly sought angles to exploit while simultaneously believing that he had and continued to be consistently wronged. To these elements one may add laziness and a propensity for acts of great stupidity. And it is in the combination of the sense of victimization with stupidity that my chief complaints with humanism lay, for humanism does not account for such qualities.

Humanism counts on a kind of self-regulation...people will act out of their own sense of justice ("do unto others as you wish others to do unto you") and commitment to principles. This works with intelligent, just people. With those who wish to do harm, and worse, those who not only do harm but turn around and accuse everyone else of doing the harm specifically to them, humanism falls short. Because ultimately, what we all want is some sort of final justice (akin to revenge, perhaps). Humanism does not provide this; it scarcely encourages it!

The prospect of God...judgment, what better way to take comfort in the lack of justice here on earth than to assume that, in death, justice will be meted out with righteous fury? Alas, humanists are often skeptical of dieties, and God is rather useless in light of that skepticism.

Authoritarian regimes...now you can be sure that, maybe not justice, but certainly punishment, will be abundant. Unfortunately, punishment is often arbitrary, and injustice is as likely to flourish--nay, inevitably thrives under these circumstances. Still....

Karma...you know, I want to believe in this. After all, it makes sense that the more good you do, the more good will you generate towards yourself and others, and the more others are willing to provide support in times of need. I have found, that on the whole a good theory, this often amounts to material and emotional assistance, and does not generally evolve into the posse required for vengeance. A mixed bag if you ask me by this merit. (For the implications of a more mystical Karma, see the notes on God.)

So I am left to forgive my enemies of all debts (yes, there are two specific people I have in mind for that particular act of humanity) and somehow assume that, by taking the high road, by preserving my moral character, by doing the right thing, even though it perpetuate and nurture injustice, I am a better person. I deserve an apology, that much is true. But I have also come to realize that people rarely get what they deserve and often get what they don't deserve (both comments in both senses...think about it...keep thinking...ok, go on). That is the way of the world, it is a fact, neither good nor bad, it just is.

It is quite irritating if you ask me.

Comments: Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?